Steak au Poivre is a French restaurant classic, which translates to “steak with pepper.” It is gratifyingly simple to make at home! A creamy sauce coats a pepper-crusted steak for a meal that feels like you opened a bistro in your very own home. 

The pepper mellows as it cooks, so what looks like an overabundance of peppercorns softens to a place where the spiciness complements and enhances the rich meat, but doesn’t compete with it.

What Kind of Pepper to Use in Steak au Poivre

Use multi-colored peppercorns for more visual appeal and different layers of peppery flavor. The different color peppercorns have distinct flavors, and when combined, add a lot of sophistication to the dish. You can find a disposable pepper grinder with three or more types of peppercorns, and you can also buy a mixed whole peppercorn blend for your own grinder.

Black pepper, however, is just fine if that’s what you have. The sauce with the brandy, cream, demi-glace or stock, and shallots will be just delicious regardless of what peppercorns you have.

Green Peppercorns in Steak au Poivre

Then there are the green peppercorns, which add a finishing touch to the sauce. Green peppercorns are underripe peppercorns, and the flavor milder than that of black peppercorns. The type of green peppercorns called for in this (and many other recipes that call for green peppercorns) are actually brined and sold in jars, unlike the dried peppercorns usually sold in bottles or bags. They add a briny salty punch to the dish. You can find them in supermarkets, specialty stores and online.

What Steak to Use in Steak au Poivre

Some recipes for steak au poivre call for a whole beef tenderloin, some call for filet mignon, shell steaks, T-bone steaks, and more. I picked a New York strip steak for this because they are juicy, well-marbled, and easy to slice, but you can use whatever tender cut of beef you like.

How to Make Easy Demi-Glace

You can purchase demi-glace in a small container at specialty stores or online. Or make your own demi-glace by reducing the best lower-sodium stock you can buy by half to concentrate the flavor. Because regular stock can contain a lot of sodium, I recommend starting with low- or less-sodium stock.

How to Crush Peppercorns for Streak au Poivre

There are a number of ways to crack the peppercorns so they are in coarse bits. You can put them in a plastic bag, seal it, and then gently pound with a meat mallet or a rolling pin or another heavy unbreakable kitchen item. Or, if you have a grinder with adjustable settings, set the grinder for the coarsest setting and grind away. You can also put the peppercorns in a mortar and gently crush them with the pestle. 

Or place them in a skillet and use a smaller pot to press and crunch the peppercorns until they are of a coarse ground consistency.

How to Make Steak au Poivre

1. Preheat the oven to 400 degrees F.
2. Heat a large, heavy skillet, preferably cast iron, over high heat. Pat the steaks dry with paper towels or a clean dish towel. Season with salt. 
3. Then coat both sides of the steaks evenly with the cracked pepper, pressing it gently into the meat to adhere.

4. When the pan is hot, add the oil and place the steaks in the hot skillet and cook until the bottom of the steaks has nicely browned, about 4 minutes.

5. Flip the steaks and transfer the pan to the oven. Bake for about 5 to 7 minutes, until the center of the steak registers 125 F on an instant-read or meat thermometer (for medium-rare). Remove the pan from the oven and transfer the steaks to a cutting board to rest for at least 5 minutes while you make the sauce.
6. Place the skillet over medium heat with any remaining fat in the pan. Add the shallots to the skillet and stir for 2 minutes until the shallots have softened.

7. Carefully pour in the brandy, then cook for an additional 2 minutes to reduce the liquid by half and cook off the alcohol. Be careful as the cognac might ignite, which is fine; the flames will quickly die out on their own. Pour in the demiglace or stock, cream, and vinegar and simmer for 3 to 5 minutes, until the sauce has thickened and is well combined.

8. Add the green peppercorns and butter and stir to melt the butter.

9. Serve the steak whole or sliced with the pepper-cream sauce.

What to Serve With Steak au Poivre

• Mashed Potatoes
• Roasted Potatoes
• Potato Gratin
• Cherry Tomato Salad
• Caesar Salad
• Baked Potato
• Creamed Spinach

More Steak Recipes

• New York Strip Steak with Jalapeño Butter
• Skirt Steak Tacos
• Marinated Petite Filets
• Marinated and Grilled London Broil